The Haunting Weight of History: Why Stephen Graham Jones’s “The Buffalo Hunter Hunter” Stays With You

Some horror books stay with you not just because they’re terrifying—but because they speak a truth more chilling than fiction alone could ever offer.

Stephen Graham Jones’s The Buffalo Hunter Hunter is exactly that kind of book.

The story takes place primarily in 1912 in the American West and is told mostly through the diary entries of a Lutheran pastor who is transcribing the confessions of a Blackfeet vampire.

Blending the visceral terror of horror fiction with the very real history of the Marias Massacre, Jones has created a novel that is both profoundly unsettling and deeply resonant. Known for pushing boundaries within the horror genre, Jones—a prolific Indigenous author—crafts a story that turns colonial violence into a source of reckoning, not just memory.

This isn’t horror for shock value. It’s horror with purpose.

Historical Horror That Hits Hard

The historical foundation of the book—the Marias Massacre—is devastating in itself. But Jones doesn’t stop at memorializing the violence; he builds a revenge narrative around it, flipping the power dynamic and asking what it means when the past doesn’t stay buried.

In doing so, he reclaims a story of trauma and turns it into something both cathartic and unsettling. It’s a book that holds a mirror to America’s violent colonial history—and dares you not to look away.

A Narrative Structure That Echoes the Classics

One of the things I found most impressive was the frame narrative, which immediately brought to mind Frankenstein. The novel begins and ends with the modern perspective of the Lutheran pastor’s descendant. This structure connects the present to the past with elegance and intensity, reinforcing one of the book’s central themes: the past is never truly over.

Jones uses this structure not only as a storytelling device, but as a way to remind readers that the echoes of violence and injustice carry into the present. It's literary horror at its most thoughtful.

Language That Demands Immersion

The prose is intentionally unfamiliar, reflective of both the historical setting and the unique voice of the vampire character, Good Stab. At first, the language might feel like a challenge—it’s not modern, and there are terms that go untranslated. But that’s the point.

This is a book that asks for your full attention. It doesn’t simplify itself for the reader—and in return, it offers a deeper, more immersive experience. You’re not just reading; you’re entering a world that isn’t built for ease but for truth.

Atmosphere That Refuses to Let Go

And yes—this book is genuinely terrifying.

The emotional and psychological tension is relentless. It’s suffocatingly eerie, steeped in grief, anger, and ancestral echoes that make the horror feel all too real. There’s sorrow. There’s rage. And there’s a lingering sense that what haunts us most is what we refuse to confront.

Jones maintains this tension masterfully from beginning to end—and it’s that emotional weight that makes The Buffalo Hunter Hunter so remarkable.

Final Thoughts

This won’t be a book for every reader—but for those willing to engage with its intensity, The Buffalo Hunter Hunter is one of the most rewarding and thought-provoking horror novels of recent years.

It’s a story about colonialism, justice, memory, and the power of storytelling itself. And while it might demand patience, focus, and an open heart, it absolutely delivers on every level.

If you’re looking for horror that matters—this is it.

Find more horror we love in our Bookshop.org storefront:

📚 Have you read The Buffalo Hunter Hunter yet? What did you think? Let’s talk about it in the comments. Because some books demand to be discussed—loudly.

📌 Looking for more powerful horror reads? Check out our Blind Date with a Book packages featuring stories that challenge, inspire, and linger long after the last page.